A federal judge in Washington, D.C. denied a preliminary injunction on November 18, 2026, allowing the Education Department to continue moving borrowers who were in the SAVE plan into other repayment plans. The ruling rejected a request to revive the REPAYE plan as a low-cost alternative. If you were enrolled in SAVE and haven't yet chosen a new plan, you need to act now — or your servicer will place you on the standard repayment plan, which typically carries the highest monthly payment.
A federal judge handed student loan borrowers a significant setback last week. On November 18, 2026, a U.S. District Court judge in the Havens v. U.S. Department of Education case denied the plaintiffs' request for a preliminary injunction. The ruling means the Education Department can keep moving former SAVE borrowers out of that defunct plan — and into new ones — while the broader lawsuit continues.
For the roughly 7.5 million borrowers who were enrolled in SAVE at its peak, this decision matters. Here's what actually happened and what your options are right now.
What the Court Decided
The borrowers in the Havens case argued that when the Eighth Circuit struck down the SAVE plan, the predecessor plan — REPAYE (Revised Pay As You Earn) — should have automatically come back to life. If that legal theory had succeeded, millions of borrowers could have transferred into REPAYE rather than the pricier alternatives.
The judge rejected that argument for now. She found the borrowers had not demonstrated the "irreparable harm" required for emergency relief. The Department of Education had also argued that plaintiff Heather Havens would actually do better under IBR than under REPAYE — an argument the court apparently found persuasive at this stage.1
7.5 million
Critically, the November 18 ruling is not a final decision on the merits. The judge has not yet ruled on whether REPAYE legally revived when SAVE was struck down. The court also has not decided the Department's motion to dismiss the case. The Havens lawsuit is still live — this was only the emergency relief phase.2
What It Means in Plain Terms
The ruling gives the Education Department the green light to continue the transition process without pausing. That means:
- Servicers are actively moving borrowers who haven't picked a plan to alternative income-driven options
- If you don't choose a plan yourself, you may be defaulted to the standard repayment plan — typically a 10-year schedule that carries the highest monthly payment of any option
It does not mean the SAVE plan is permanently dead by judicial order — the Eighth Circuit struck it down earlier, and that ruling stands regardless of Havens.
Your Options Right Now
The good news: you still have income-driven options. The Education Department has confirmed four plans remain available for borrowers who need affordable payments based on income:1
- IBR (Income-Based Repayment) — available for most federal loan borrowers; forgiveness after 20–25 years
- PAYE (Pay As You Earn) — capped at 10% of discretionary income; available to newer borrowers
- ICR (Income-Contingent Repayment) — broadest eligibility but typically the highest payment among IDR plans
- Repayment Assistance Plan — a newer option introduced as SAVE wound down; check studentaid.gov for current terms
If you do nothing, your servicer may move you to the standard repayment plan. Monthly payments under standard repayment are recalculated on the remaining balance and loan term — for many borrowers, this means payments that are two to four times higher than what SAVE required. Log into studentaid.gov or call your servicer to confirm your current plan status.
Three Things Most Articles Don't Tell You
1. The REPAYE question isn't settled. The November 18 ruling is an injunction denial, not a final ruling on whether REPAYE legally revived. If a future ruling finds REPAYE did come back, that could change the landscape — but that outcome is not guaranteed and could be years away. Don't wait on a legal outcome to protect your monthly budget.
2. If you're close to forgiveness, IBR is the safest switch. The College Investor, which tracks student loan litigation closely, noted that borrowers nearing the end of a forgiveness timeline should prioritize IBR because it preserves qualifying payment counts for income-driven forgiveness more reliably than some newer options.2 If you're in year 15 of a 20-year forgiveness plan, your plan choice now could affect whether you reach forgiveness on schedule.
3. Switching plans doesn't erase your payment history. Under current rules, prior qualifying payments made under SAVE and other IDR plans count toward IBR's forgiveness clock. You should still confirm this with your servicer before switching, but the payment count typically carries over — it doesn't reset to zero.
Before calling your servicer, check your loan history at studentaid.gov first. Log in, go to "My Aid," and look at your payment count under IDR. This gives you a baseline to verify that the servicer carries your count over correctly when you switch plans.
What to Do Today
- Log into studentaid.gov — confirm which plan you're currently on and your payment count
- Pick an IDR plan — if you don't choose, your servicer will choose for you
- Submit the application through your servicer's website, not a third-party service
- Keep records — download your payment history and confirmation of any plan switch
If you need help understanding your options, see our guide to student loan repayment plans and income-driven repayment explained. For background on where SAVE came from and how borrowers got here, see our earlier coverage: SAVE plan ends — what borrowers must do and SAVE plan 90-day deadline and new options.
If you're also worried about longer-term forgiveness, review student loan forgiveness programs to understand which plans remain eligible and what the current status of PSLF and IDR forgiveness is after the OBBBA.
The Bottom Line
The November 18 court ruling is not the end of the Havens lawsuit, but it is a clear signal that SAVE borrowers should not wait for a legal rescue. The plans available today — IBR, PAYE, ICR, and the Repayment Assistance Plan — can keep payments manageable. The window to act on your own terms, rather than have a servicer decide for you, is still open. Use it.
Footnotes
-
Minsky, A. (2026, November 19). Student loan borrowers face major setback after court allows repayment plan changes. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamminsky/2026/11/19/student-loan-borrowers-face-major-setback-after-court-allows-repayment-plan-changes/ ↩ ↩2
-
The College Investor. (2026, November 19). SAVE plan lawsuit: Judge denies bid to revive REPAYE, what's next for borrowers. The College Investor. https://thecollegeinvestor.com/92703/save-plan-lawsuit-judge-denies-repaye-revival/ ↩ ↩2